Curio Critique # 7: When handwriting matters!
July 16, 2017
Curio Critique # 9: Soul-based education!
July 16, 2017
Show all

Curio Critique # 8: Instruction in the vernacular medium

HTML Table Header
Sl. No. Curio Book Title Year of Publication
8 The Punjab Educational Journal Vol 1. No. 4 June 1905 1905

Curio Book

 
 

Curio reference

In the 1905 edition of the journal, there is a reference to the views expressed by Sir Guru Das Banerji in the Indian Spectator...: “teach English only as a second language up to the age of fifteen, not ... as a medium of instruction in other subjects”:

Related references

One hundred years later, the world over, vernacular education is being given due prominence. This is echoed in the content of the Blog post of the website of Global Partnership for Education, entitled Children Learn Better in Their Mother Tongue
The Hunter Education Commission (1882-83), we know, insisted on imparting of primary education through the vernacular. Interestingly enough, Charles A. Sauer half a century later, summed up his article entitled ‘The place of the Vernacular Language in Colonial Education’(1943) thus:
Colonial education should begin in the mother tongue, and even on the secondary level the social sciences should be taught in the vernacular. The official language is a necessity in the secondary school, particularly in the sciences. The transition from the vernacular to the official language should be gradual and made on the upper elementary grades.

Source http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1540-4781.1943.tb00205.x/abstract
It is a puzzle why the teaching of vernacular languages is not well received in India. Sahith Aula provides a plausible answer in his opinion post entitled The Problem With The English Language In India in the Forbes website:
Indians have come to believe that their nation’s prosperity, as well as their own, is wholly dependent upon not just learning English, but exclusively learning it as a first language. It began with the travelled elite, boomed within the middle class that was hired by multinational companies, and trickled to the vast majority hoping to escape their destitution but unable to afford private English education. Curiously, many states in India have attempted to make English the medium of instruction for all schools in an attempt to assuage the demands of the poor; however, the shortage of teachers who can even speak English is surreal. All of this while the vast majority is able to communicate in their respective mother tongues.
Source https://www.forbes.com/sites/realspin/2014/11/06/the-problem-with-the-english-language-in-india/#1c511724403e
Curio Quest Is instruction in the vernacular relevant any more in the age of globalization?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *